Tolstoy or Dostoevsky: An Essay in the Old Criticism by George Steiner
Published 1959 · 384 pages · 110,000 words · about 11 hours at an average pace · Essays & Criticism
How many words are on a page? A ReadingRate study
How hard is Tolstoy or Dostoevsky: An Essay in the Old Criticism to read?
Tolstoy or Dostoevsky: An Essay in the Old Criticism scores 66 out of 100 for difficulty on ReadingRate, making it quite demanding. The score is a weighted composite of nine measures: four of how hard the prose is to parse, five of how hard the meaning is to extract.
- Vocabulary: 68 out of 100
- Erudite comparative vocabulary drawing on theology, philosophy, and aesthetics.
- Sentence structure: 65 out of 100
- Abstraction: 78 out of 100
- Operates at the level of competing metaphysics and aesthetics.
- Information density: 76 out of 100
- Every paragraph carries significant comparative or analytical weight.
- Argumentative complexity: 72 out of 100
- Steiner constructs a sustained, multi-faceted comparative argument, meticulously analyzing Tolstoy's and Dostoevsky's worldviews, narrative techniques, and philosophical stances across dimensions like history, evil, and the sacred. The reader must track a complex dialectic between two major literary-philosophical systems, often presented in tension, requiring more than implied argument but less than a full philosophical treatise.
- Prerequisite knowledge: 70 out of 100
- The work demands extensive familiarity with the major novels of Tolstoy and Dostoevsky, as well as a strong background in European literary history, philosophy (e.g., Hegel, Nietzsche), and theology. Without this foundational knowledge of primary texts and intellectual traditions, the nuances of Steiner's comparative analysis are largely inaccessible.
- Terminological opacity: 55 out of 100
- Steiner employs a precise academic vocabulary drawn from literary criticism, philosophy, and theology, but he does not invent neologisms or use highly opaque, field-specific jargon. The interpretive difficulty stems more from the complexity of the concepts themselves and their interrelations rather than from obscure or undefined terminology.
- Rhetorical indirection: 45 out of 100
- Steiner's arguments are presented directly and analytically, employing rigorous scholarly prose to articulate his comparative theses rather than relying on indirect methods. While the analysis is deep and nuanced, it does not use aphoristic compression, deconstruction, or mimetic strategies to convey its meaning, making its claims relatively straightforward to follow.
- Systemic scope: 78 out of 100
- The essay synthesizes literary criticism, philosophy (metaphysics, ethics, history), theology, and intellectual history to construct its comprehensive comparison. Steiner draws on a vast range of intellectual traditions and academic domains to illuminate the profound differences and similarities between Tolstoy and Dostoevsky, creating a broadly interdisciplinary analysis.
How Tolstoy or Dostoevsky: An Essay in the Old Criticism is regarded
Tolstoy or Dostoevsky: An Essay in the Old Criticism holds a literary regard score of 85 out of 100, weighing its place in the canon, its critical reception, its influence on other writers, and the standing of its author. Regard is measured separately from difficulty: a demanding book is not necessarily an admired one.