The Only Good Indians by Stephen Graham Jones
Published 2020 · 384 pages · 87,713 words · about 6 hours at an average pace · horror, literary fiction, Indigenous literature, supernatural thriller
How many words are on a page? A ReadingRate study
How hard is The Only Good Indians to read?
The Only Good Indians scores 48 out of 100 for difficulty on ReadingRate, making it moderately challenging. The score is a weighted composite of nine measures: four of how hard the prose is to parse, five of how hard the meaning is to extract.
- Vocabulary: 38 out of 100
- Jones writes in contemporary vernacular with Blackfeet cultural terms scattered throughout: po'noka (elk), sweat lodge terminology, reservation slang. The prose stays grounded in working-class American English with hunting and basketball vocabulary. No literary archaisms or invented language. Blackfeet words appear sparingly and context supplies their meaning.
- Sentence structure: 52 out of 100
- Jones builds long, run-on sentences that mimic internal thought spiraling outward, with em dashes and digressions that pile clause upon clause. The effect resembles a mind unable to stop circling back. Paragraphs sometimes stretch across pages without visual breaks. Yet each individual clause remains grammatically simple, keeping the syntax accessible despite its cumulative density.
- Abstraction: 42 out of 100
- The novel operates primarily through concrete physical action: gutting elk, shooting basketballs, walking through snow. Philosophical content emerges obliquely through characters' rationalizations and guilt rather than explicit meditation. Jones never pauses for abstract essays; ideas about cultural obligation and ecological revenge surface through bodies and blood.
- Information density: 40 out of 100
- Jones parcels out backstory in drips, returning repeatedly to the Thanksgiving Classic elk hunt from different angles. Individual scenes unfold at a deliberate pace with extensive sensory detail. The novel carries one central mystery rather than layered informational demands. Readers track a limited cast across four sequential sections.
- Narrative indirection: 55 out of 100
- The elk entity's presence is signaled through eerie detail rather than exposition: a woman whose hair moves wrong, a dog that recognizes something its owner cannot. Jones withholds the nature of the threat for the first third. The second-person sections from the elk's perspective require readers to reconstruct who is narrating and why, though the core plot remains legible.
- Symbolic density: 62 out of 100
- The elk functions as a sustained, multivalent symbol: wronged nature, Indigenous tradition violated, female vengeance, the dead demanding acknowledgment. The sweat lodge, basketball games, and hunting each carry cultural weight beyond their literal function. Jones layers the title's historical echo (referencing the genocidal phrase about Indians) across every death in the novel.
- Ironic distance: 35 out of 100
- Jones writes from genuine proximity to his characters' experience, without satirical detachment. The humor is dark and self-deprecating in the characters' own voices rather than an authorial commentary from above. When Lewis jokes about avoiding Indian stereotypes, the tone is survival humor, not literary irony.
- Resolution withholding: 38 out of 100
- The novel resolves its supernatural threat decisively. Each section ends with clear narrative closure, often violent death. Denorah's final basketball game provides a definitive conclusion to the elk's pursuit. Jones does not withhold answers about what happened or leave the central conflict ambiguous. The open question is emotional rather than narrative: whether the debt is paid.
- Structural complexity: 58 out of 100
- The novel divides into four named sections following different protagonists, with the second-person narration from the elk's perspective representing a genuine formal experiment. POV shifts between third-person limited and second-person require recalibration. The nonlinear relationship between the inciting hunt and each character's present-day reckoning creates a spoke-and-hub architecture rather than a linear timeline.
How The Only Good Indians is regarded
The Only Good Indians holds a literary regard score of 52 out of 100, weighing its place in the canon, its critical reception, its influence on other writers, and the standing of its author. Regard is measured separately from difficulty: a demanding book is not necessarily an admired one.
Where The Only Good Indians sits in Northrop Frye's Anatomy of Criticism
Placed by a full reading of the text (158 passages), not from reputation. Each verdict quotes the passage that earned it. On the axis from myth to irony, The Only Good Indians scores 80 out of 100. A second mythos, romance, pulls at it with a weight of 0.25. About the map of stories.
- Mode: Ironic
Her dad is Gabriel Cross Guns. He’s the one who shot the hole in your back, took your legs away.
- Symbol: Mythical
Indian stories always hoop back on themselves like that, don’t they? At least the good ones do.
- Mythos: Irony & Satire vi (irony vi)
“Then there was me,” Gabriel mumbles, smiling a sloppy smile, and closes the door.
- Genre: Romance + Novel
Like he’s been doing for years, he imagines the headline on the Glacier Reporter back home: FORMER BASKETBALL STAR CAN’T EVEN HANG GRADUATION BLANKET IN OWN HOME.
Where the story of The Only Good Indians takes place
- Blackfeet Reservation, Browning, East Glacier and Duck Lake, Montana, Thanksgiving week, present day (2017 to 2019), the main setting
- Duck Lake elders' section, the Thanksgiving Classic hunt, ten years earlier (2007 to 2009)
- Williston, North Dakota oil-patch bar parking lot, ten years earlier (2007 to 2009)
- Great Falls, Montana: Lewis and Peta's rent house and the post office, the week before Thanksgiving (2017 to 2019)
5 things that are true of The Only Good Indians, with the passage for each
The book opens with the headline that will be written about Ricky's death: INDIAN MAN KILLED IN DISPUTE OUTSIDE BAR.
The headline for Richard Boss Ribs would be INDIAN MAN KILLED IN DISPUTE OUTSIDE BAR.
Lewis has been married to Peta for ten years when the main story begins.
is having been married ten years now to Peta
Gabe counts nine elk lying dead on the slope after the hunters fire.
counted nine huge bodies down there in the snow, each probably pushing five hundred pounds.
Lewis kills his coworker Shaney by starting his motorcycle so her hair is dragged into the spinning rear wheel.
It takes maybe half a second for those chrome spokes to grab her long spiral curls, crank her head both up and to the side, her neck obviously cracking.
The elk calf Lewis carries to the end is named Po'noka, which means elk.
Her name in Blackfeet is Po’noka.
Scenes in The Only Good Indians that Frye would name
63 sightings of Frye's terms in the text. The strongest:
- Sparagmos, untitled
It takes maybe half a second for those chrome spokes to grab her long spiral curls, crank her head both up and to the side, her neck obviously cracking.
Shaney's body is torn apart by the motorcycle wheel in a visceral dismemberment.- Sparagmos, untitled
The next crunch is wetter, the one after that deeper, punching through into a darker space.
Gabe beats Cassidy's skull in with a thermos in the sweat-lodge massacre.- Agon, untitled
This time, talking to the young elk the whole while, promising her that he was going to use every bit of her if she would just please die, he nestled the barrel right against her face
Lewis's struggle to kill the cow elk who will not die is the quest's central combat.- Sparagmos, untitled
slamming that dog into nothing, into a red chunky smear, teeth here, flash of bone there, matted fur all in and among.
Harley is trampled into pieces, the first act of the elk's revenge.- Pathos, untitled
The cracking sound of her skull opening up is distinct, and permanent, and looking away doesn’t help Lewis process it, or accept it.
Peta's death on the hearth is the sacrificial scene of the Lewis section.- Pathos, untitled
When they shoot is when he finally feels what he’s been waiting for, what he’s been gambling on, praying for: long delicate legs against his chest, kicking once, twice, again.
Lewis is shot dead holding the elk calf; his death comes with a birth.
Books that share these scenes with The Only Good Indians
- Demonic imagery: 1984, The Fellowship of the Ring, Wuthering Heights
- Anagnorisis: Jane Eyre, The Bacchae, The Reader
- Sparagmos: 1984, The Bacchae, The Old Man and the Sea
- Cognitio: Jane Eyre, Wuthering Heights, Exes and O's
- Pathos: The Fellowship of the Ring, Bring Up the Bodies, The Idiot
- Pharmakos: The Ones Who Walk Away from Omelas, 1984, The Penelopiad
- Hamartia: Wuthering Heights, Outer Dark, The Picture of Dorian Gray
- Agon: The Old Man and the Sea, Restitution, The Pilgrims Progress
- Displacement: Wuthering Heights, The Metamorphosis, Don Quixote
- Masque: Don Quixote
- Confession: The Color Purple, The Door, Lolita
- Point of epiphany: Four Quartets, King James Bible, The Wind in the Willows
- Senex iratus: A Midsummer Night's Dream
- Katabasis: Divine Comedy, Epic of Gilgamesh, The Golden Ass
- Alazon: Hard Times, The Idiot, The Wind in the Willows
- Anatomy: Waiting for Godot, Don Quixote, 1984
- Lyric: Don Juan, The Fellowship of the Ring, King James Bible
- Analogy of innocence: The Old Man and the Sea, Wuthering Heights, King James Bible
- Apocalyptic imagery: Jane Eyre, King James Bible, Howl and Other Poems
- Epos: The Fellowship of the Ring, The Idiot, King James Bible