The Plague of Doves by Louise Erdrich
Published 2008 · 352 pages · 105,487 words · about 14 hours at an average pace · literary fiction, historical fiction, polyphonic novel
How many words are on a page? A ReadingRate study
How hard is The Plague of Doves to read?
The Plague of Doves scores 77 out of 100 for difficulty on ReadingRate, making it very challenging. The score is a weighted composite of nine measures: four of how hard the prose is to parse, five of how hard the meaning is to extract.
- Vocabulary: 68 out of 100
- The text incorporates specialized cultural terms like "Mooshum," "Metis," and "snoose," alongside specific religious vocabulary such as "scapulars" and "transubstantiation." Occasional literary words like "murmurous susurration" and scientific terms like "prognathic jaw" also appear, requiring readers to engage with a lexicon beyond common contemporary fiction.
- Sentence structure: 70 out of 100
- Sentences frequently extend to considerable length, employing multiple subordinate clauses and descriptive phrases to convey intricate details and internal thoughts. While generally grammatically clear, the prose demands sustained attention to navigate its elaborate structures, comparable to the navigability of long paragraphs in "2666."
- Abstraction: 72 out of 100
- The narrative, though grounded in concrete events of reservation life and family history, consistently delves into philosophical and symbolic territory. Billy Peace's abstract sermons on Armageddon and the Antichrist, combined with the narrator's internal reflections on justice, identity, and the nature of spirit, elevate the content beyond a purely literal interpretation, akin to the metaphysical digressions found in "Gravity's Rainbow."
- Information density: 78 out of 100
- The novel presents a complex tapestry of intergenerational family history, shifting first-person narrators, and embedded historical events, demanding high attention from the reader. Intricate relationships, cultural details, and thematic layers are woven throughout, creating a dense informational experience that requires careful tracking of connections, similar to the demands of "War and Peace" or "2666."
- Narrative indirection: 80 out of 100
- The novel frequently requires readers to infer meaning, employing multiple first-person narrators whose perspectives are often limited, biased, or explicitly unreliable, such as Mooshum's embellished historical accounts. Events are layered through generations of storytelling, demanding readers to actively connect disparate narratives and interpret the subjective experiences of characters like Evelina and John Wildstrand. This approach, reminiscent of *Pedro Paramo*, prioritizes reader assembly of meaning over direct exposition.
- Symbolic density: 80 out of 100
- Symbolism is deeply woven throughout the narrative, starting with the literal and metaphorical 'Plague of Doves' which represents both natural and colonial forces. Recurring motifs like salamanders, embodying both devilish and emissary roles, and the turtle with carved initials, signifying enduring love and loss, carry significant meaning beyond their literal presence. Billy Peace is explicitly framed as a 'Christ figure' or 'martyr,' elevating his actions to an allegorical level, making the text richer than *The Great Gatsby*.
- Ironic distance: 75 out of 100
- A pervasive ironic distance exists between the characters' perceptions and the deeper truths, particularly evident in the humorous yet critical portrayal of Father Cassidy's hypocrisy and the community's selective morality. John Wildstrand's elaborate kidnapping scheme, designed to resolve his personal life, ironically leads to unforeseen consequences and his own downfall. This subtle critique of human folly and societal norms creates a gap between what is said and what is truly meant, akin to the nuanced irony in *Lolita*.
- Resolution withholding: 78 out of 100
- The narrative consistently resists definitive closure, leaving many questions and emotional arcs open-ended, reflecting the enduring impact of historical trauma and personal struggles. Mooshum's fluid storytelling about the lynching of Holy Track and others highlights the elusiveness of a single 'truth,' while the adult Evelina's final reflections on Billy Peace's transformation and her mother's resignation ('No one's ever going to stop him') underscore a lack of neat resolution. This approach creates a lingering ambiguity, similar to *The Crying of Lot 49*.
- Structural complexity: 85 out of 100
- The novel exhibits high structural complexity through its non-linear chronology and shifting first-person perspectives, moving between Evelina's childhood, Antone Coutts's courtship, and historical expeditions. Chapters like 'SOLO' serve as enigmatic prologues, while the interwoven narratives of different generations and families (e.g., Milk, Peace, Coutts, Wildstrand, Buckendorf) demand constant reorientation from the reader. This multi-layered and fragmented structure, more intricate than *Midnight's Children*, requires active engagement to piece together the overarching story.
How The Plague of Doves is regarded
The Plague of Doves holds a literary regard score of 82 out of 100, weighing its place in the canon, its critical reception, its influence on other writers, and the standing of its author. Regard is measured separately from difficulty: a demanding book is not necessarily an admired one.
Prizes
- Pulitzer Prize for Fiction 2009, finalist
Where The Plague of Doves sits in Northrop Frye's Anatomy of Criticism
Placed by a full reading of the text (193 passages), not from reputation. Each verdict quotes the passage that earned it. On the axis from myth to irony, The Plague of Doves scores 66 out of 100. A second mythos, comedy, pulls at it with a weight of 0.3. About the map of stories.
- Mode: Low Mimetic
We are a tribe of office workers, bank tellers, book readers, and bureaucrats.
- Symbol: Mythical (archetypal)
Those doves were surely the passenger pigeons of legend and truth, whose numbers were such that nobody thought they could possibly ever be wiped from the earth.
- Mythos: Irony iv (tragic pathos) (irony iv)
Now that some of us have mixed in the spring of our existence both guilt and victim, there is no unraveling the rope.
- Genre: Novel + Confession
even as I sat there listening to Mooshum my fingers obsessively wrote the name of my beloved up and down my arm or in my hand or on my knee.
Where the story of The Plague of Doves takes place
- Pluto and the reservation, North Dakota, 1960s–1970s (1960 to 1975), the main setting
- Town-site expedition on the Dakota prairie and the Peace brothers' canoe race, 1880s (1880 to 1888)
- Saint Joseph's and the plague of doves, 1896
- Lochren farm murders and lynching, 1911
- Wildstrand, Neve and Billy Peace's kidnapping, 1950s–60s (1950 to 1965)
- Dying Pluto and its historical newsletter, 2000s (2000 to 2008)
5 things that are true of The Plague of Doves, with the passage for each
The book opens in 1896, with a priest leading parishioners to pray away a plague of doves.
IN THE YEAR 1896, my great-uncle, one of the first Catholic priests of aboriginal blood, put the call out to his parishioners
Father Cassidy collapses after slipping on a salamander that Evelina's brother Joseph had stocked in a pond.
“He slipped on a salamander,” I said.
Billy Peace is struck by lightning while sitting on an iron bench during a rain prayer.
A rope of golden fire snakes down and wraps Billy twice. He goes entirely black.
Corwin smashes Shamengwa's violin on a communion rail at the old man's funeral.
Corwin raised the violin high and smashed it on the rail, once, twice, three times to do the job right.
Evelina's father's rare stamps crumble to dust after his car rolls into a beet field.
When he lifted the stamp with a tweezers, it fell into a little heap of incredibly precious dust, which he caught as it sifted down.
Scenes in The Plague of Doves that Frye would name
40 sightings of Frye's terms in the text. The strongest:
- Pathos, untitled
The boy was too light for death to give him an easy time of it. He slowly choked as he kicked air and spun.
The hanging of Holy Track, with Cuthbert and Asiginak, is the book's central sacrificial death.- Anagnorisis, untitled
“Turn them over,” I said.
Evelina forces Mooshum to recognise Holy Track's boots and, with them, his own betrayal at the lynching.- Alazon, untitled
From the Latin, concupisserry, I believe, meaning, ah, to dwell upon unclean emissions in one’s past
Father Cassidy's pompous, drunk and mangled Latin makes him the braggart impostor.- Pharmakos, untitled
We are no-goods, we are Indians, even me. If you tell the white sheriff, we will die.
Asiginak states the logic of scapegoating that dooms the innocent men.- Lyric, untitled
They began high—Cuthbert’s voice a wild falsetto that cut the air.
The death song is an embedded overheard lyric, sung at the gallows.- Epos, untitled
THE STARS ARE the eyes of God and they have been watching us from the beginning of the earth.
Billy's tent sermon is a spoken oration to a crowd.
Books that share these scenes with The Plague of Doves
- Demonic imagery: 1984, The Fellowship of the Ring, Wuthering Heights
- Anagnorisis: Jane Eyre, The Bacchae, The Reader
- Sparagmos: 1984, The Bacchae, The Old Man and the Sea
- Cognitio: Jane Eyre, Wuthering Heights, Exes and O's
- Pathos: The Fellowship of the Ring, Bring Up the Bodies, The Idiot
- Pharmakos: The Ones Who Walk Away from Omelas, 1984, The Penelopiad
- Hamartia: Wuthering Heights, Outer Dark, The Picture of Dorian Gray
- Agon: The Old Man and the Sea, Restitution, The Pilgrims Progress
- Displacement: Wuthering Heights, The Metamorphosis, Don Quixote
- Masque: Don Quixote
- Confession: The Color Purple, The Door, Lolita
- Point of epiphany: Four Quartets, King James Bible, The Wind in the Willows
- Senex iratus: A Midsummer Night's Dream
- Katabasis: Divine Comedy, Epic of Gilgamesh, The Golden Ass
- Alazon: Hard Times, The Idiot, The Wind in the Willows
- Anatomy: Waiting for Godot, Don Quixote, 1984
- Lyric: Don Juan, The Fellowship of the Ring, King James Bible
- Analogy of innocence: The Old Man and the Sea, Wuthering Heights, King James Bible
- Apocalyptic imagery: Jane Eyre, King James Bible, Howl and Other Poems
- Epos: The Fellowship of the Ring, The Idiot, King James Bible