Giving an Account of Oneself by Judith Butler
Published 2005 · 176 pages · 52,296 words · about 6 hours at an average pace · Nonfiction, Philosophy, Ethics
How many words are on a page? A ReadingRate study
How hard is Giving an Account of Oneself to read?
Giving an Account of Oneself scores 75 out of 100 for difficulty on ReadingRate, making it very challenging. The score is a weighted composite of nine measures: four of how hard the prose is to parse, five of how hard the meaning is to extract.
- Vocabulary: 82 out of 100
- Butler deploys highly specialized philosophical and psychoanalytic vocabulary throughout — 'assujettisement,' 'poiesis,' 'desubjugation,' 'nachträglichkeit,' 'interpellation,' 'normativity,' 'subjectivation,' 'enigmatic signifiers,' 'thing-representations' — alongside extensive Continental philosophy shorthand requiring familiarity with Hegel, Foucault, Levinas, and Lacan. The text presupposes fluency in both analytic and Continental philosophical traditions, placing it well above the literary vocabulary of 2666 and approaching the specialized density of Gravity's Rainbow, though without scientific jargon.
- Sentence structure: 72 out of 100
- Sentences regularly extend through multiple embedded qualifications and reversals, as Butler builds an argument by simultaneously affirming and limiting each position she examines. A typical sentence might run: 'Although some would say that to be a split subject, or a subject whose access to itself is forever opaque, incapable of self-grounding, is precisely not to have the grounds for agency and the conditions for accountability, the way in which we are, from the start, interrupted by alterity may render us incapable of offering narrative closure for our lives.' This Jamesian hypotaxis is demanding but more controlled than Faulkner's 1,000-word sentences or Proust's extended subordination.
- Abstraction: 90 out of 100
- The text operates at near-total abstraction. Concrete scenes are almost entirely absent; the brief literary examples (Kafka's Georg, Odradek) serve as philosophical illustrations rather than sustained narrative. The entire work is conducted at the level of conceptual argument — the 'I,' accountability, recognition, opacity, normativity, the scene of address — with no grounding in particular persons or events. This matches Waiting for Godot's existential abstraction in its refusal of the concrete, while exceeding it in philosophical density.
- Information density: 85 out of 100
- Each paragraph introduces new philosophical moves, engages a new thinker, or pivots the argument through a fresh framework. Within a single chapter Butler mobilizes Adorno, Nietzsche, Hegel, Foucault, Levinas, Cavarero, Laplanche, Winnicott, Bollas, and Lacan — tracking how each framework illuminates and limits the central question of self-accounting. Readers must hold multiple theoretical positions in view simultaneously and track how Butler's own argument relates to each. The density approaches Ulysses's encyclopedic demands, though the domain is narrower.
- Argumentative complexity: 76 out of 100
- Butler builds a three-chapter argument that the subject's opacity to itself grounds rather than defeats responsibility, holding Nietzsche, Foucault, Hegel, Laplanche, Levinas and Adorno in tension and correcting each against the others. The reader must track claims about norms, address and the unnarratable origin at once, close to the Of Grammatology anchor.
- Prerequisite knowledge: 80 out of 100
- Butler assumes working familiarity with Nietzsche's Genealogy, late Foucault on critique and care of the self, Hegelian recognition, Levinas's Otherwise than Being, Laplanche's enigmatic message, Winnicott and Bollas, and Adorno's Problems of Moral Philosophy. Readers without these sources lose the force of her corrections, placing the work above Orientalism and near Negative Dialectics.
- Terminological opacity: 70 out of 100
- The prose leans on borrowed technical terms: regime of truth, subjectivation, preontological persecution, thing-representation, transference, holding environment, Entschlossenheit. Butler glosses some, such as Laplanche's primary impressions, but most arrive mid-argument, comparable to the Discipline and Punish anchor.
- Rhetorical indirection: 62 out of 100
- Butler advances her thesis through readings of other thinkers and of Kafka's The Judgment and Odradek, and her long sentences perform the dispossession they describe, as when she writes that we must laugh here at narrating a beginning. Claims surface through qualification and rhetorical questions rather than direct statement, above Mythologies but below Phenomenology of Spirit.
- Systemic scope: 72 out of 100
- The lectures join moral philosophy, Foucaultian social theory, Hegelian recognition, two psychoanalytic schools, Levinasian and Jewish ethics, critical theory and literary criticism of Kafka, with a political critique of Levinas on Israel. The breadth approaches the Orientalism anchor, though everything converges on the single question of ethical accountability.
How Giving an Account of Oneself is regarded
Giving an Account of Oneself holds a literary regard score of 74 out of 100, weighing its place in the canon, its critical reception, its influence on other writers, and the standing of its author. Regard is measured separately from difficulty: a demanding book is not necessarily an admired one.
Where Giving an Account of Oneself sits in Northrop Frye's Anatomy of Criticism
Placed by a full reading of the text (101 passages), not from reputation. Each verdict quotes the passage that earned it. On the axis from myth to irony, Giving an Account of Oneself scores 80 out of 100. A second mythos, comedy, pulls at it with a weight of 0.15. About the map of stories.
- Mode: Ironic
The “I” is the moment of failure in every narrative effort to give an account of oneself.
- Symbol: Literal & Descriptive
Telling a story about oneself is not the same as giving an account of oneself.
- Mythos: Irony and Satire iv (tragic pathos) (irony iv)
The “I” ruins its own story, contrary to its best intentions.
- Genre: Anatomy + Confession
At least, let’s hope not, since, over wine usually, I tell it in various ways, and the accounts are not always consistent with one another.
Where the story of Giving an Account of Oneself takes place
- Continental philosophy lectures, Amsterdam, Princeton and Frankfurt, 2001-2003 (2001 to 2004), the main setting
- Socratic, Cynic and Stoic Greco-Roman scenes of parrhesia, as read by Foucault (400 BCE to 200)
- Adorno's letter to Benjamin (1934) and Frankfurt moral philosophy lectures (1963) (1934 to 1963)
5 things that are true of Giving an Account of Oneself, with the passage for each
The book grew out of lectures given at the University of Amsterdam in spring 2002.
The chapters of this book were originally given as the Spinoza Lectures for the Department of Philosophy at the University of Amsterdam in the spring of 2002.
Butler illustrates Adorno's point about violent universals with President Bush's policy toward the Palestinian Authority and Iraq.
We might, along these lines, think about President Bush’s proposal for the Palestinian Authority or his efforts to replace the government in Iraq.
Georg's last words in Kafka's 'The Judgment' are an avowal of love for his parents.
dear parents, I have always loved you, all the same [Liebe Eltern, ich habe euch doch immer geliebt]
Butler reads the last sentence of 'The Judgment' as a surviving voice whose German word for traffic, Verkehr, also means sexual intercourse.
at this moment an unending stream of traffic was just going over the bridge
In Kafka's parable, Odradek answers 'No fixed abode' when the narrator asks where he lives.
“Well, what’s your name?” “Odradek,” he says. “And where do you live?” “No fixed abode.”
Scenes in Giving an Account of Oneself that Frye would name
19 sightings of Frye's terms in the text. The strongest:
- Pathos, untitled
Already he was grasping at the railings as a starving man clutches food (die Nahrung).
Georg's rushed death by drowning, the central sacrificial scene of the book's literary examples.- Senex iratus, untitled
His father condemns him to death by drowning, and Georg is rushed from the room, as if by the force of the utterance itself, and over the side of the bridge.
The condemning father of 'The Judgment' is a blocking elder in its darkest, tragic form.- Epos, untitled
The chapters of this book were originally given as the Spinoza Lectures for the Department of Philosophy at the University of Amsterdam in the spring of 2002.
The radical of presentation is spoken lecture to a live audience.- Pathos, untitled
He dies for their sins, and the charwoman who passes him on the stairs cries “Jesus!” and covers her eyes when she sees him.
Butler reads Georg's death as a sacrificial, quasi-Christological gift of love.- Lyric, untitled
I am you, If I am
Celan's overheard lyric line serves as epigraph and condensed emblem of the thesis.- Sparagmos, untitled
Another word comes our way, a blow, an address or naming that suddenly, inexplicably slaughters, even as one lives on, strangely, as this slaughtered being, speaking away.
The subject is figured as slaughtered by address yet surviving, a metaphoric tearing-apart of the self.
Books that share these scenes with Giving an Account of Oneself
- Demonic imagery: 1984, The Fellowship of the Ring, Wuthering Heights
- Anagnorisis: Jane Eyre, The Bacchae, The Reader
- Sparagmos: 1984, The Bacchae, The Old Man and the Sea
- Pathos: The Fellowship of the Ring, Bring Up the Bodies, The Idiot
- Pharmakos: The Ones Who Walk Away from Omelas, 1984, The Penelopiad
- Confession: The Color Purple, The Door, Lolita
- Senex iratus: A Midsummer Night's Dream
- Alazon: Hard Times, The Idiot, The Wind in the Willows
- Anatomy: Waiting for Godot, Don Quixote, 1984
- Lyric: Don Juan, The Fellowship of the Ring, King James Bible
- Epos: The Fellowship of the Ring, The Idiot, King James Bible
- Eiron: The Penelopiad