Consider the Lobster by David Foster Wallace
Published 2005 · 352 pages · 105,755 words · about 11 hours at an average pace · Nonfiction, Essays & Criticism
How many words are on a page? A ReadingRate study
How hard is Consider the Lobster to read?
Consider the Lobster scores 68 out of 100 for difficulty on ReadingRate, making it quite demanding. The score is a weighted composite of nine measures: four of how hard the prose is to parse, five of how hard the meaning is to extract.
- Vocabulary: 76 out of 100
- Wallace deploys words like 'euphuistic,' 'pleonastic,' 'sesquipedalian,' 'Heliogabaline,' 'petitio principii,' 'ignoratio elenchi,' and 'nociceptors' — terms drawn from rhetoric, philosophy, neuroscience, and classical logic. The SNOOT essay alone contains enough specialized linguistic vocabulary to require a dictionary nearby. Context usually clarifies meaning, but the density of rare terms is higher than 2666 and closer to Gravity's Rainbow.
- Sentence structure: 80 out of 100
- Wallace's sentences extend through multiple nested parenthetical insertions, em-dash interruptions, and footnotes that sometimes run longer than the paragraphs they annotate — the private-language demonstration in footnote 32 of 'Authority and American Usage' runs over 1,200 words. The dual-track of main text and footnotes forces the reader to hold two simultaneous arguments. Less extreme than Faulkner's 1,000-word sentences, but more structurally demanding than standard essay prose.
- Abstraction: 82 out of 100
- Essays move without warning between concrete reporting — the AAVNA awards ceremony, lobsters thrashing in supermarket tanks — and sustained philosophical argument about Wittgenstein's private language thesis, Singer's utilitarian framework for animal interests, and the ideological stakes of prescriptivist grammar. The abstraction is not ornamental; it is the point of each essay. Closer to Brothers Karamazov (75) than to journalism, because the philosophical digressions are where the argument lives.
- Information density: 80 out of 100
- The footnote apparatus creates genuine parallel texts rather than mere citation scaffolding. 'Authority and American Usage' embeds a full sociological argument about class and linguistic authority in interpolations labelled 'SEMI-INTERPOLATION' and 'AMATEUR DEVELOPMENTAL-SOCIOLINGUISTIC INTERPOLATION.' Every page requires tracking multiple conceptual threads simultaneously. The density is comparable to War and Peace (80) not because of sheer narrative mass but because each paragraph in the SNOOT essay introduces a new argument rather than developing the previous one.
- Argumentative complexity: 72 out of 100
- The 'Authority and American Usage' essay runs a sustained argument across descriptivism, prescriptivism, Wittgenstein's private language proof, sociolinguistics, and class politics — simultaneously, not sequentially. The lobster essay chains utilitarian ethics, Cartesian skepticism about animal consciousness, evolutionary neuroscience, and cultural critique into an argument that refuses easy resolution. Both essays hold multiple contradictory positions in tension as a deliberate argumentative strategy, comparable to Orientalism but with more embedded sub-arguments and greater ironic self-awareness.
- Prerequisite knowledge: 55 out of 100
- The usage essay quotes Wittgenstein's Philosophical Investigations directly and cites Derrida ('the Pharmakon stuff in La dissémination — but you'd probably be better off just trusting me'), Saussure, and Ferdinand de Saussure's parole/langue distinction. The lobster essay invokes Peter Singer's Animal Liberation as the 'bible of the modern animal-rights movement.' The Dostoevsky essay assumes the reader has read at least Crime and Punishment. The Big Red Son piece on the porn industry is largely self-contained. Background in analytic philosophy and literary theory increases comprehension substantially but is not strictly required.
- Terminological opacity: 52 out of 100
- Wallace coins the term 'SNOOT' (Sprachgefühl Necessitates Our Ongoing Tendencies) and uses specialized linguistic vocabulary — hypotaxis, discourse community, idiolect, synthetic vs. analytic language — but generally contextualizes these terms within sentences. Adult-industry jargon in Big Red Son ('woodman,' 'fluff,' 'money shot') is explicitly glossed in a dedicated footnote. The terminological load is real but not as opaque as Foucauldian vocabulary (Orientalism, 60) because Wallace anticipates reader ignorance and compensates for it.
- Rhetorical indirection: 68 out of 100
- Wallace's rhetorical signature is to argue for a position while constantly signaling his own discomfort with arguing for it. 'Consider the Lobster' reaches its sharpest ethical claim — that we should acknowledge our discomfort with boiling lobsters alive — and then withdraws: 'I am not trying to spoil anyone's fun in saying this. I am also not suggesting that you don't go ahead and boil that lobster.' The SNOOT essay defends prescriptivism while repeatedly apologizing for the elitism of prescriptivism. Arguments are stated but immediately hedged, qualified, and undone by the voice that states them.
- Systemic scope: 65 out of 100
- The collection ranges across moral philosophy (animal ethics), analytic philosophy of language (Wittgenstein), linguistics (descriptivism vs. prescriptivism, Saussure), cultural criticism (pornography and American media industry), literary biography and Slavic studies (Dostoevsky), rhetorical theory, humor theory, and political journalism (the McCain campaign essay). No single essay operates across all these domains, but the collection as a whole synthesizes them into a coherent intellectual project about sincerity, ethics, and American culture.
How Consider the Lobster is regarded
Consider the Lobster holds a literary regard score of 75 out of 100, weighing its place in the canon, its critical reception, its influence on other writers, and the standing of its author. Regard is measured separately from difficulty: a demanding book is not necessarily an admired one.